Situation Guide · Public entity claims

A 50-h examination is a pre-suit municipal claim examination—not a court hearing before a judge.

After a Notice of Claim, certain municipalities can demand an examination about what happened and the injuries or damages being claimed. The process can involve sworn oral questions, counsel, and in some cases a physical examination.

What can happen

Four features of the statutory examination.

These are parallel features of the process, not a required step-by-step sequence.

  • Sworn oral questions

    The statute describes an oral examination unless the parties otherwise stipulate. The testimony is taken under oath or affirmation.

  • Right to counsel

    The claimant has the statutory right to be represented by counsel at the examination.

  • Possible physical examination

    A demand can also include a physical examination under the statute. That is a separate part of the municipal claim process.

  • A record can matter later

    Questions and answers are recorded, and the transcript may later be used by either party in an action founded on the claim.

What the statute examines

The occurrence and the claimed injuries or damages.

This page explains subject matter at orientation depth. It does not tell a particular claimant how to answer a question, assert a privilege, object, or prepare testimony.

  • What happened

    Section 50-h permits examination about the occurrence underlying the claim.

  • The claimed injuries or damages

    The examination can also address the extent of the injuries or damages for which the claim is made.

Timing without a countdown

The statute uses “90 days” in more than one way.

One timing rule concerns the demand itself.

Section 50-h contains a rule about when a written demand must be served to be effective. That is not the same thing as saying every examination must occur within one universal 90-day deadline.

Another rule concerns commencement after a demand.

If a qualifying examination is not conducted within the statutory period after the demand, § 50-h addresses when an action may be commenced. Claimant-caused failure to appear, adjournment, or postponement can change that analysis.

Separate deadline: § 50-i expressly states that § 50-h does not itself extend the period for starting the action. This page therefore does not calculate a filing deadline.

Keep the legal objects separate

A 50-h examination is not four other things people may confuse it with.

  • Notice of Claim

    The earlier notice mechanism is a different procedural object. A 50-h examination may follow it; the examination is not the notice itself.

  • Ordinary post-suit deposition

    A 50-h examination occurs in the municipal pre-suit claim process. Calling it “just a deposition” hides important differences.

  • Settlement conference

    The statutory examination is not a hearing whose legal purpose is to negotiate or approve a settlement.

  • Limitations extension

    General Municipal Law § 50-i expressly says the 50-h process does not itself extend the separate period for starting the action.

A practical first pass

Start with the document in front of you.

  • Keep the actual demand or scheduling notice and identify the public entity named on it.
  • Note the date the demand was received or served, plus the scheduled time and place shown on the document.
  • Check whether the demand refers only to oral questioning or also states that a physical examination is required.
  • Write down the questions you want to ask counsel rather than trying to solve testimony, privilege, adjournment, or deadline issues from a generic webpage.

Do not upload or send the demand, medical records, testimony notes, or other private documents through this public page.

General information, individual questions

The page can explain the process. It cannot decide what your demand requires.

Whether a demand is valid, whether an adjournment or missed appearance matters, what questions must be answered, and when an action must be commenced are fact-specific legal questions.

Brian Berger is the lawyer responsible for this page's content. About Brian →

To discuss an individual situation, choose how to begin.