Situation Guide · Courts & appeals

“Can I appeal?” starts with the ruling and the court that made it.

New York appellate routes depend on where the case started, what judgment or order was entered, and whether review is available as of right or only by permission. Further review is not automatically available just because a party disagrees with the result.

Three questions first

The word “appeal” does not answer the route.

  • Where did the case start?

    The originating court helps determine the appellate court and procedural statute.

  • What was entered?

    Judgments and orders are not all treated the same way, and finality can matter.

  • As of right or by permission?

    Some appellate review is available as of right; other review requires leave or permission.

Ordinary Brooklyn first-review paths

The first appellate court depends on where the case began.

These examples identify ordinary civil routes. They do not say that a particular ruling is appealable.

Starts inNYC Civil Court · Kings County
Ordinary first appellate courtAppellate Term · 2nd, 11th & 13th Judicial Districts
Starts inSupreme Court · Kings County
Ordinary appellate departmentAppellate Division · Second Department

Right versus permission

Some review is as of right. Other review requires permission.

The governing statute and the type of determination matter. A public guide cannot safely classify an individual order from a short description.

Appeal as of right

Statutes such as CCA 1702 and CPLR 5701 identify categories in which an appeal may be taken as of right.

Appeal by permission

Other determinations require leave or permission from the court identified by the governing appellate statute.

Current CCA §1702 was revised June 19, 2026.

Small Claims is different

Small Claims review is intentionally restricted.

NYC Civil Court Act §1807 states that a claimant commencing a Small Claims action waives ordinary appeal rights, except that either party may appeal on the sole ground that substantial justice has not been done according to the rules and principles of substantive law.

That is not the same appellate framework as an ordinary Civil Court case.

Higher review

There is no automatic “keep appealing” ladder.

These are separate legal gates, not consecutive guaranteed steps.

  • Appellate Term → Appellate Division

    CPLR 5703(a) requires permission from the Appellate Term or, after refusal, the Appellate Division. It is not an automatic next appeal.

  • Appellate Division → Court of Appeals

    Court of Appeals review is limited to specified as-of-right routes or qualifying permission routes under CPLR Article 56.

  • The dissent rule

    The familiar as-of-right dissent route requires at least two Appellate Division justices dissenting on a question of law in favor of the appellant, plus the statute’s other requirements.

What an appeal is

Appellate review is not simply a new trial.

Review

An appellate court reviews a lower court determination under the applicable appellate rules and standards, using the appropriate appellate record and submissions.

Not a do-over

An appeal is not simply a chance to retry the facts, add whatever new material a party wants, or obtain another hearing because the result was disappointing.

Maintained official resources

Use the current appellate court instructions for the procedural task.

Discuss a specific ruling

Choose how to begin.

Do not submit private court records or a complete case file on this public page.