Situation Guide · Courts & appeals

The amount of money does not decide State versus federal court.

Federal district courts need a basis for subject-matter jurisdiction. A large claim, a serious dispute, or a reference to federal law does not by itself decide whether a Brooklyn civil case belongs in federal court.

Two parallel systems

The first question is what gives the court power to hear the case.

New York State courts

Broad State-court jurisdiction across many civil matters

New York's court system includes Supreme Court, NYC Civil Court, Court of Claims and other specialized forums. The correct State forum still depends on jurisdiction, defendant, relief and procedure.

Federal courts

Limited subject-matter jurisdiction

Federal district courts hear cases Congress and the Constitution place within federal jurisdiction. Brooklyn is within the Eastern District of New York.

Two common federal bases · not an exhaustive list

Federal question and diversity answer different jurisdiction questions.

Federal law contains additional specialized grants of jurisdiction. Federal question and diversity are two common examples; the sections below explain why neither money nor a federal-sounding issue is enough by itself.

Diversity jurisdiction

More than $75,000 is only one part of the analysis.

Ordinary diversity jurisdiction under §1332 requires both a qualifying citizenship relationship and the statutory amount in controversy.

Qualifying citizenship

The parties must fit the citizenship categories required by the statute and governing law. Citizenship, domicile, and entity citizenship can require detailed analysis.

Amount exceeds $75,000

The statutory language is “exceeds” $75,000, exclusive of interest and costs—not “at least” $75,000. This requirement does not replace the citizenship requirement.

$75,000 does not “get” a case into federal court. The statute says the amount must exceed $75,000, exclusive of interest and costs, and the citizenship requirement must also be satisfied.

Federal-question jurisdiction

There is no general dollar threshold under §1331.

Section 1331 covers civil actions arising under the U.S. Constitution, federal laws, or treaties. The statute does not impose a general amount-in-controversy requirement.

That does not mean every case mentioning federal law belongs in federal court. Whether a civil action legally “arises under” federal law is itself a jurisdiction question.

Cases and claims can be more complicated than two boxes

Removal and supplemental jurisdiction are separate doctrines.

This page identifies them so the State/Federal distinction is not oversimplified. It does not decide removability, remand, citizenship, timing, or strategy.

Removal · §1441

Some civil actions filed in State court may be removed by defendants when federal original jurisdiction and the removal statutes permit it. Additional restrictions and procedures apply.

Supplemental jurisdiction · §1367

When a federal court has original jurisdiction, sufficiently related claims may sometimes travel with the federal claim under the supplemental-jurisdiction statute, subject to statutory limits.

Appellate orientation

The federal appellate path is separate from the State appellate system.

Federal trial court in BrooklynU.S. District Court · EDNY
Ordinary appeal from final district-court decisionsU.S. Court of Appeals · Second Circuit

U.S. Supreme Court review is not automatic.

Under §1254 and current Supreme Court Rule 10, certiorari review is discretionary. Rule 10 states that certiorari is not a matter of right.

Some final State cases can present a federal question to the U.S. Supreme Court.

Section 1257 permits certiorari review of qualifying final judgments from the highest State court in which a decision could be had when specified federal questions are presented.

These routes do not make federal courts a general appellate layer above New York State courts, and this page does not decide whether any particular order is appealable.

Current official sources

Check the jurisdiction rule before choosing the court label.

Discuss an individual jurisdiction question

Choose how to begin.

Do not submit private documents or a complete case file on this public page.