Legal guide · Personal injury process

What happens in a New York personal injury lawsuit?

A claim and a lawsuit are not the same thing. A personal injury claim can exist before a lawsuit is filed, and some matters resolve without a lawsuit. If an action is filed, the court process has a general structure—but not every case goes through every possible event or reaches trial.

Before a lawsuit · outside the litigation spine

Some important work or decisions can happen before a case is filed.

This is context—not “Step 0.” What happens before suit depends on the facts, parties, governing law, and whether special prerequisites apply.

  • Information already available

    Records, event information, care information, and other existing material may be organized before any lawsuit is filed.

  • Insurer or pre-suit communication

    Insurance communications or resolution discussions can occur before litigation. This page does not tell you what to say, sign, or accept.

  • Special prerequisites, when applicable

    Claims involving a public entity can have separate notice, presentment, examination, or forum rules. Those are not universal lawsuit stages.

  • Filing and timing decision

    Whether and when an action should be filed depends on the matter. This guide is not a deadline calculator.

Public-entity rules are separate. A Notice of Claim is not a universal first stage of a personal injury lawsuit, and different public defendants can have different procedures. See Claims Against NYC & Public Entities for the separate public-entity orientation.

The general litigation backbone

Four broad phases have a real procedural relationship.

The sequence below is intentionally broad. It does not say that every lawsuit completes every phase, that each phase starts at a fixed time, or that the case cannot resolve along the way.

  1. Pleadings / commencement

    A New York civil action is commenced by filing the papers required by CPLR § 304. Pleadings frame the claims and defenses that are being put before the court.

    This is not a service-of-process, answer-deadline, venue, or filing-form tutorial.

  2. Discovery

    CPLR § 3101 provides the general scope for disclosure of matter material and necessary to the prosecution or defense of an action. Discovery can include documents, testimony, and other relevant information.

    Discovery can clarify, complicate, support, or weaken disputed positions. It does not automatically make a case stronger.

  3. Pretrial / trial readiness

    Unresolved issues, witnesses, evidence, and trial preparation are organized as the case moves toward readiness. Court conferences and scheduling can vary by court and case.

    Motions or settlement can alter the path before trial. There is no universal court calendar on this page.

  4. Trial — if the case gets there

    If the matter has not otherwise resolved and issues remain for decision, a judge or jury may decide those issues at trial under the rules that apply to the case.

    Trial is a possibility, not a guaranteed destination. This page gives no trial probability, duration, or result prediction.

The arrows stop with this backbone. Settlement, motions, conferences, experts, medical authorizations, examinations, and appeals are not being represented as mandatory numbered stages.

Things that can happen during the case

These events are possibilities—not the next six steps.

They can occur at different points, repeat, overlap, or never occur at all. Their placement here does not recommend a strategy or predict what a particular case will require.

  • Motions

    A party may ask the court to decide an issue during the case. Summary judgment under CPLR § 3212 is one example of a motion that can resolve all or part of an action without a trial; motions are not a mandatory stage.

  • Settlement / ADR

    Resolution discussions can occur before suit or during litigation. Mediation, arbitration, or another process may be relevant depending on the matter and governing agreements or rules.

  • Conferences / scheduling

    Courts may use conferences and scheduling orders to manage a case. The exact sequence and timing are court- and case-specific.

  • Expert work

    Expert analysis or testimony may become relevant to liability, causation, injury, or damages depending on the issues. Not every case uses the same experts or expert process.

  • Medical records / authorizations

    When physical condition and injury-related damages are at issue, relevant medical information can become part of litigation discovery, subject to the governing rules and protections.

  • Defense-requested examination

    When physical or mental condition is in controversy, CPLR § 3121 can permit a party to request an examination by a designated physician and related authorizations under the rule.

Personal-injury discovery literacy

Some unfamiliar parts of an injury case are really discovery questions.

  • A deposition is not a trial

    A deposition is sworn testimony taken during discovery before trial. It is one way information can be developed; this page does not provide testimony coaching.

  • Medical information can enter discovery

    When the claimed physical condition and damages are in controversy, relevant records, authorizations, and examinations may become part of the litigation process.

  • The evidentiary picture can change

    Discovery can add information that changes how disputed facts and legal positions are understood. New information can help, hurt, or complicate either side’s position.

Maintained official resources

Use New York Courts and current statutes for generic court mechanics.

Brooklyn Lawyer adds PI-specific orientation. The court system and current statutes remain the maintained sources for generic procedure and statutory text.

Related Brooklyn Lawyer orientation: New York Legal Deadlines · How New York Courts Work.

Discuss an individual process question

Choose how to begin.

Do not submit medical records, litigation papers, privileged communications, or a complete case file on this public page.